How to Increase Rent Without Losing Tenants (PLUS: Free Raise the Rent Letter)


Written by:

The Big Picture On How To Increase Rent Without Losing Tenants:

    • Understanding local rental laws is essential for legally implementing rent increases, ensuring landlords comply with specific regulations regarding notice periods and maximum allowable rent hikes.
    • Effective tenant communication about rent increases, including the reasons behind them and any corresponding property improvements, can maintain good relationships and decrease tenant turnover.
    • Offering renewal incentives, such as slight discounts or upgrades, can motivate tenants to accept new lease terms under higher rents, balancing the increase with added tenant value.

The information provided on this website is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal, financial, or investment advice. 

Always consult a licensed real estate consultant and/or financial advisor about your investment decisions. 

Real estate investing involves risks; past performance does not indicate future results. We make no representations or warranties about the accuracy or reliability of the information provided. 

Want a better return on your rental investments?

Landlords must understand how to tactfully and effectively raise rents without losing tenants. Turnovers can be costlier than a Kardashian’s wardrobe, so to maximize ROI, you need to minimize turnover while keeping rent on the rise.

Here’s what landlords need to know about rent increase letters, legal limitations, and how to raise the rent without losing tenants.

Why You Need To Raise Rent?

Before talking about how landlords can raise rents, let’s talk about the why.

Reason to Raise Rent Description
Market Rate Adjustments To align the rent with current market rates, ensuring it reflects the value of similar properties in the area.
Cost of Living Increases To keep up with rising costs associated with property maintenance and operations, such as taxes, utilities, and insurance.
Property Improvements To fund upgrades and renovations that enhance the property’s value and appeal, thus justifying higher rents.
Increased Property Value Following property assessments that indicate an increase in value, landlords might raise rents to match the enhanced property worth.
Regulatory Changes Adjusting rents in response to changes in housing laws or local ordinances that affect rental properties.

Know the Market Rent

It doesn’t matter if you do everything else on this list right. If you try to raise the rent above local market rental rates, your tenants will balk.

And then they won’t renew your lease agreement, leaving you with a vacant rental unit and a costly turnover. Which will leave your net profits for the year lower, not higher, and defeat the purpose of raising the rent.

So, do your homework before raising the rent. Start with free resources like Zillow, to check nearby rental comps.

Another resource you can access is PropStream. While Propstream is primarily designed as a real estate investing tool to find under-valued properties, it comes with powerful market analytics.

One final tool worth mentioning is Mashvisor. Among other functions, Mashvisor helps you analyze the local rental market and includes comparisons for Airbnb rentals versus long-term rental returns.

You can also check rental listings on oldie-but-goodie Craigslist, which remains popular and well-used by both landlords and tenants to this day.

How Much to Raise the Rent?

Feel confident in a number for your rental unit’s market rent?

Before you go raising the rent to that exact number, pause to consider how much of a rent increase you’re talking about. Calculate the percentage rent increase, over your current rent.

A good rule of thumb: don’t raise the rent by more than 5% per year. Any more, and the sharp rent increase often jolts the tenant into moving – even if you’re raising the rent no higher than nearby market rates.

Say you’re currently renting the property for $1,000, and after analyzing local comps, you decide the market rent is $1,100. Instead of raising the rent by $100 all at once, consider raising it by $50 this year, and another $50 next year.

And never, ever raise the rent by more than 10%, if you want to keep your tenants. No matter how much your tenants like the rental unit and get along with you, they will balk if you raise the rent by more than 10%.

Most people’s budgets can’t handle their rent going up by hundreds of dollars a month. If your rent is dramatically below market value, raise it gradually, in manageable increments over the course of several years.

You should send a raise-the-rent letter every year, so don’t put yourself and your renters in a situation where the rent is so far below market pricing that you consider a huge hike. But we’re getting ahead of ourselves, more on that shortly.

Serve the Rent Increase Letter Before the Deadline

Many lease agreements include a specified notice period, for notifying the other party about changes in the lease renewal. As a landlord, you must send a written rent increase letter before that period.

But the lease agreement isn’t the only factor. Most states impose minimum notice requirements as well.

Common notice periods are 30 or 60 days before the current lease agreement ends, although they can be as long as 90 or even 120 days. If the lease ends on April 30, and the lease and local laws require a 30-day notice period for any changes to the leasing agreement, the landlord must serve the rent increase notice on the tenant by March 31 at the latest.

With that said, landlords should serve the notice with time to spare. The tenants needs time to decide, and time to respond to your rent increase notice. If they opt to non-renew, you’ll need time to advertise the rental unit and screen tenants, ideally before the outgoing tenant leaves, to minimize your vacancy.

It’s worth mentioning that the same notice period applies to non-renewal of the lease, if you want your tenant to move out at the end of the current lease term.

Check your state landlord-tenant laws before setting a notice period for raising the rent, and follow it to the letter when you serve a raise-the-rent notice!

How to Serve a Raise-the-Rent Letter

Each state has different legal options for serving rent increase letters. The most common service options include:

  • Certified mail
  • Hand delivery
  • Posting the raise-the-rent letter on the front door
  • Regular mail

When in doubt, serve the rental increase letter by certified mail, because it leaves you with a receipt to prove delivery.

Remember to mail it several days in advance – snail mail takes time!

Rent Increase Letter Sample

Where can landlords find a rent increase letter sample?

Glad you asked. We offer a free raise-the-rent letter through our landlord app, accessible by all account levels (including the Free account).

Here’s a video showing how you can create and print a rent increase letter in under 60 seconds using our landlord app:

You can create a free account here and generate your rent increase letter less than a minute later.

Watch Out for Rent Control & Section 8

In many markets, rent control is a reality for landlords.

The market rent doesn’t matter in those cases; you can’t charge market rents. All you can charge is what’s allowed by local rent control laws.

If your rental is in a rent-controlled area, make sure you check the local laws for maximum rent increase rates, and don’t surpass them. Exceed the maximum rent increase rate and you risk fines, plus angry tenants.

Keep in mind that Section 8 sometimes restricts rent increases as well. If you rent to Section 8 tenants, check with your local Section 8 office about annual limits before you raise the rent.

5 Tricks to Raise the Rent Without Losing Any Tenants

Want higher tenant retention rates?

You should. The average tenant turnover costs thousands of dollars in vacancies, repairs, maintenance such as repainting and new carpets, and new tenant leasing costs (whether to a property manager or in your own lost hours of labor).

But no one wants to hear that their rent is increasing. So how can you deliver this bad news without alienating your best tenants?

1. Raise the Rent Every Year, Even If Only Slightly

Every year, like clockwork, you should send a raise-the-rent notice. Even if it’s only by $10-20.

Why? Isn’t that just spiteful with no real income bump?

No, it actually has nothing to do with the money. The point is to set expectations – you are reinforcing the notion that the rent goes up every year, no exceptions. Don’t worry, none of your renters will go through the hassle of moving over $15/month.

Maybe neighborhood demand is stable this year, so you’re only raising the rent to keep pace with inflation. Or maybe demand in the area has skyrocketed, and you need to boost the rent significantly to keep pace with the market. Regardless, you’re sending a message: grass is green, gravity falls downward, and rent goes up every year.

2. Pave the Way with Good Relations.

Long before you ever need to raise the rent, you’ll be signing the initial lease agreement with the tenants and probably contacting them by phone a few times over the course of the first year. You’ll already know their children’s names from the rental application, and you’ve probably met their children at least once.

A simple way to warm parents to you is to ask about their children by name. You don’t need to actually remember their names; just pull out the rental application before you call them and ask how Little Bobby is doing. If they moved from another school district, you can always ask how the kids are doing in the new school.

If the tenants don’t have kids, you can always ask about their job, or a quirky hobby of theirs.

Keep a few notes each time you talk to your tenants, so you can reference them the next time you call them. It will take you thirty seconds to keep and reference these notes, but even this basic level of human contact will warm your relationship from “This landlord just wants a rent check” to “She’s a nice woman.”

3. Deliver the News by Phone (But Still Send an Increase in Rent Notice)

By law, you need to send written increase of rent letter, usually 30-60 days in advance (as outlined above). In some states, it’s as high as 90 or even 120 days’ written notice.

By the laws of common courtesy, you should deliver bad news gently, by phone. No one likes to open a piece of mail that says “Surprise! You owe me an extra $100/month starting next month.”

Be polite, firm, professional, and add the slightest hint of remorse (don’t overdo this last). Explain that you know it’s bad news, but rent for the new lease period will be higher than the last. If they ask why, simply tell them the rent rises every year alongside neighborhood rents and inflation.

Tell them that you would like to keep them as tenants, and that you hope they continue to rent with you. You’re now positioned to offer them an alternative.

lease agreement renewal4. Offer a Reduced Raise in Rent If They Sign a Long-Term Lease Renewal

“Pay more” or “leave” don’t have to be the only two options. What if you could offer a third option that allays their worries and keeps your rental unit occupied for years to come?

One option you can give them is to sign a multi-year lease agreement and have the rent only rise by $X instead of $Y.

Or you don’t have to offer any discount on the rent hike this year, but you can offer to let them avoid next year’s rent hike by locking in this rent for two years (or even three!).

Long-term tenants are where landlords make high returns. Turnovers are expensive, between lost rent, new paint, new carpets, advertising, screening tenants, and possibly paying a leasing agent or property manager.

5. Ask Tenants About Property Improvements and Consider Them

Talking to tenants about upgrades is a little tricky because you don’t want the tenant to tie the idea of upgrades to the idea of rent hikes. Over the course of the year, ask the tenant what property upgrades would make the most difference to them, if they could wave a magic wand. If you manage a large building, consider a formal survey; if it’s just a few tenants, ask around verbally.

Consider which desired upgrades would have the biggest impact on your long-term asking rent. If you could spend $1,500 and be able to charge another $75 in rent, then in under two years that upgrade will have paid for itself. Property upgrades also incentivize tenants to renew their lease and stay long-term.

If possible, make the upgrades after raising the rent instead of just before. You can offer it as an inducement to renew long-term: “By the way, I took to heart your suggestion of installing new countertops. I’ve put down a deposit, and the workers will be coming next week.”


Bonus: Personalize Your Rent Increases—But Do It Smartly

There are places where not all tenants pay the same rent. This gives landlords some leeway on how to raise rent for specific tenants or give it a more personalized touch by considering their history, how long they’ve been renting, or if they’ve been generally good tenants.

Here are a few ways you can personalize rent increases.

    • Assess each tenant’s situation and offer something that they might value
    • Communicate with them, or even open up negotiations
    • Offer flexible terms and other incentives aside from reduced rent for longer terms

However, you need to be very, very careful when personalizing rent increases. You need to be fully aware of the landlord-tenant regulations to see if it’s allowed. You must also be fully equipped with facts and records that support why you increased your rent that way. As a landlord, you must also communicate how you came to this decision. It can help avoid a nasty discrimination suit.

One more thing: never, ever use rent to target a tenant, or to force them to a decision. Personalize your rent increases, but remain objective and don’t take things personally.

If you succeed in personalizing your rent increases, you may just end up with long-term tenants with happier dispositions (or at least as happy as they could be with rising rents.)

Final Thoughts On How To Raise Rent

It’s a delicate dance, raising the rent. It takes tact, professionalism, friendliness, and firmness, but if handled right, your tenants will all renew their lease agreements. Higher rents and longer-term lease contracts? A recipe for higher ROI.♦

Have any tips for raising the rent? Any bad experiences? Tenants ever chase you out with a pitchfork? We love stories… share in the Comments section below!

This article originally appeared on SparkRental and was syndicated by MediaFeed.

More from MediaFeed

Like MediaFeed’s content? Be sure to follow us.