Strangest unsolved mysteries of all time


Written by:

The world is a crazy place. We’ve found skeletons wrapped in tree roots, bleeding walls, mysterious unending fires, and more. The creepiest part? The reasons for these strange happenings remain a mystery. Here are a few of the strangest, creepiest and most fascinating mysteries we’ve found across the U.S.

Robert Fisher
United States FBI

America’s Most Wanted

Until 2021, Robert William Fisher was one of the FBI’s 10 most wanted fugitives. On April 10, 2001, Fisher murdered his wife and two children. He blew up their home in Scottsdale, Arizona, and vanished the night of the accident. He remains the only suspect, and it’s unsure if he ended his life or is living under a new name.

dbvirago / iStock

Escape from Alcatraz

The infamous 1962 escape from Alcatraz Island in San Francisco Bay ended in 33 prisoners who attempted to escape losing their lives. However, prisoners John Anglin, Clarence Anglin, and Frank Morri managed to drill holes in their cells and escape. It’s still unclear where the prisoner went, as they were never caught.

Related: These wild historic facts sound fake but aren’t

Black Forest, Colorado
Jeffrey Beall / Wiki Commons

The Black Forest haunting

The Lee family’s home sweet home in Colorado Springs’ Black Forest turned into a nightmare, and fast. Shortly after moving in, family members reported flashing lights, footsteps, eerie classic movies, odd smells, and the occasional ghost. A Hopi shaman said the house was a rip in the space-time continuum, so ghosts and other spirits used the Lee’s home to move in and out of different worlds.

New Haven, Connecticut
Wiki Commons

An unknown epidemic

During Hurricane Sandy in 2012, Hurricane Sandy a tree in New Haven Green, Connecticut came crashing down. The spooky part? There were human skulls over 200 years old in its roots, and archeologists found more body parts and even coffin nails, too. Experts believe over 5,000 bodies were buried in unmarked graves over 200 years ago in New Haven Green. No one is sure why, but it is believed to be the result of an unknown epidemic.

Mary Reeser
Wiki Commons

The curious combustion of Mary Reeser

In July 1951,67-year-old Mary Reeser was found in her St. Petersburg apartment. However, only her lower leg and spine were recognizable, as the rest of her body was simply ash. It appeared that she had been cremated on the spot, although that process usually entails burning a body for over three hours with a whopping 3,000-degree flame. And the other mysterious part? Only her body was burned; nothing in her apartment was scorched, not even the newspapers sitting next to her ashes.

Creepy house
beest / iStock

Georgia’s Bleeding House

Imagine waking up to find blood on your flood. That’s what happened to Atlanta homeowner Minnie Winston in 1987. She reportedly ran to her husband, who was perfectly fine. But once she came back to the blood, she found even more of it. It was coming out of the floors, the walls, and even under appliances in their kitchen. Police were not able to find the cause of the bleeding, but they were able to confirm that it was indeed human blood.

Creepy farm
BrilliantEye / iStock

Strange mutilations

In the 1970s, something strange started happening in Jerome and Bliss in Idaho. Humans, cattle, deer, and more have been found dead with missing private parts and all the blood drained from their bodies. While no forensic evidence has ever been found, local law enforcement blamed the murders on cults, although they haven’t arrested anyone or found the alleged cult in question.

Creepy gas mask
vovashevchuk / iStock

The Mad Gasser of Mattoon, Illinois

In the 1940s, over two dozen “gassings” were reported throughout Mattoon. Victims reported coughing, nausea, vomiting and even paralysis right after smelling something odd in their home. None of the victims died, and many even chalked up the reports to mass hysteria. However, many believe it was caused by the “Mad Gasser” or some paranormal creature.

Burned down home
OlgaKorica / iStock

Indiana’s fire poltergeist

In 1941, a farmer in Odon saw smoke coming from his home while working on his farm. With the help of the fire department, they put out the fire. However, as soon as they put one fire out, another would start in another room of the house. By the end of the day, they had put on 28 fires. Not taking any chances, the farmer, who believed a poltergeist was at work, tore down the home and built a new one. No official cause has been found.

Boy child refusing to eat
patat / iStock

The boy without an appetite

In 2013, Landon Jones from Cedar Falls, Iowa, was diagnosed with a bacterial infection in his left lung. Ever since the infection, he claims he doesn’t ever feel hungry or thirsty and needs to be reminded to eat. Doctors still are unsure what caused this to happen.

Related: Last-minute Halloween recipes & party ideas

EzumeImages / iStock

It’s raining … meat?

In 1876, chunks of meat rained down on a farm in Kentucky. While no one knows for sure what really happened (or even what type of meat fell from the sky), some believe that vultures had overeaten and vomited above the farm from the air.

Hidden creepy tunnels
miksov / iStock

Maryland’s hidden home tunnels

In 2017, a Bethesda home caught on fire. But that wasn’t the mysterious part. Investigators found a dead body in the basement, along with hidden tunnels under the home’s foundation that went all the way to the street. Daniel Beckwitt, the homeowner, was charged with murdering Askia Khafra, whose body was found in his basement. Investigators believe Beckwitt hired Khafra to dig the holes in dangerous conditions, resulting in his death. However, the reason for building the tunnels in the first place remains a mystery.

Related: 25 unusual (or just plain weird!) roadside attractions

Creepy shadow figure
innovatedcaptures / iStock

The black flash of Massachusetts

From 1939 to 1945, Provincetown residents reported being attacked by a group of tall kids dressed in black who growled at their victims. And in 1945, a group of police officers even allegedly saw a “black flash” leap over a 10-foot fence. A month or so after the police sighting, a townsman threw boiling water at the “black flash,” which screamed and ran away. No further sightings were reported.

Creepy lantern
HenrikNorway / iStock

The Paulding Light

In 1966, teens from Paulding, Michigan reported an odd light above a valley. While some have suggested swamp gas was the cause, many more believe that light was actually from a lantern of a brakeman from the area who was killed trying to stop a train. More scientist Michigan Tech students say the light is probably from headlights, but no official cause has been found.

Rastan / iStock

New Jersey’s phantom sniper

In 1927, Camden was under attack by a phantom sniper. Bus and car windows were shattered, a police officer was shot, and yet bullets or casings were never found. The other odd part? No one ever saw the alleged sniper. One witness claims to have heard a man laughing. The attacks stopped in 1928, and no one is sure of what actually happened to this day.

Creepy crawl space attic
Svetlana Evgrafova / iStock

The murderer in the crawl space

In Niagara, North Dakota, six bludgeoned bodies were found in a crawl space belonging to a recluse named Eugene Butler in 1915. Butler had died in 1911, a few years after being committed to a mental hospital. The strangest part? While the town had less than 100 residents, no one knew who the six victims were. Their identities remain a mystery today.

Woman with hands over her ears
Nektarstock / iStock

Shrieks in Forest Grove

In 2016, the sleepy town of Forest Grove, Oregon received several reports of paranormal-sounding shrieking that would fill the air but whose source remained unclear. While they sounded like a train on metal tracks, there isn’t a train near Forest Grove. Almost as soon as the shrieks appeared, they stopped. The cause of the noise remains unsolved. Related: 15 creepy ghost tours across America

panida wijitpanya / iStock

The box boy

In 1957, a young boy’s body was found in a cardboard box in a wooded area just outside Philadelphia. Authorities could not identify the boy, and no one reported a missing boy matching his description. While there were no clues, a psychic in 1960 took police to a foster home where the psychic believed the boy had lived. However, police were unable to connect the boy to the foster home.

Lizard man
SerrNovik / iStock

The lizard man

In the summer of 1988, Browntown, South Carolina residents reported seeing a “lizard man” who was seven-feet tall with red eyes and superhuman strength. Someone reported seeing the lizard man mal a car. Sightings of the lizard man have occurred as recently as 2015.

Tetiana Strilchuk / iStock

The Bennington Triangle

Vermont’s Bennington Triangle is in Glastenbury Mountain. It got its nail after a trail guide vanished in 1945. A college student disappeared while hiking there a year later, and then another person vanished a year later. The disappearances stopped after the 1940s. Many believe it was either a serial killer or some paranormal presence.

Creepy bunk beds
Dennis Diatel Photography / iStock

The haunted bunk beds

In 1987, the Tallman family bought a used bunk bed for the home in Horicon, Wisconsin. For the nine months they had the bunk bed, the family reported strange hauntings, including clock radios turning themselves, a paintbrush that dipped itself in paint, their children becoming sick, and even an unexplained fire. The family destroyed the bed, and the hauntings stopped.

Creepy foggy boat
Mayehem / iStock

The Investor murders

In 1982, an $850,000 fishing boat, The Investor, burned off the coast of Craig, Alaska. Eight bodies, including the owner, his pregnant wife, their two daughters, and four crew members, were found shot on the boat. One suspect was tried and acquitted, and the case remains unsolved.

Icy road warning sign on a snowy road
trendobjects / iStock

Frozen alive

In 1981, Jean Hillard’s car swerved off the road and into a lake near Langby, Minnesota. The next day, her frozen body was found. Her eyes were wide open, her skin was solid that it couldn’t even be pierced with a needle, and her temperature was so low that it wouldn’t register on a thermometer. However, Hillard thawed and was found to be alive. She made a full recovery, miraculously … and mysteriously.


This article was produced and syndicated by


Kaitlyn Farley

Kaitlyn is MediaFeed’s senior editor. She is a graduate of Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism, specializing in social justice and investigative reporting. She has worked at various radio stations and newsrooms, covering higher-education, local politics, natural disasters and investigative and watchdog stories related to Title IX and transparency issues.