The pros & cons of buying a car online


Written by:

Have you ever thought of buying a car online before? I certainly haven’t. As much as I love technology and the idea of having just about anything delivered to my door, cars are one product I figured you just had to purchase through traditional means.

But then I interviewed someone who regularly buys cars online, often using Craigslist and similar sites to do so.

“Do people really do that,” I asked, “It seems kind of … difficult to know if you can trust it.”

And then he dropped this on me: “How well do you trust your local car dealership?”


SPONSORED: Find a Qualified Financial Advisor

1. Finding a qualified financial advisor doesn't have to be hard. SmartAsset's free tool matches you with up to 3 fiduciary financial advisors in your area in 5 minutes.

2. Each advisor has been vetted by SmartAsset and is held to a fiduciary standard to act in your best interests. If you're ready to be matched with local advisors that can help you achieve your financial goals get started now.





Touche. Here’s what I learned from that interview and the pros and cons of buying a car online.

Pros of buying a car online

  • You don’t have to haggle with professional salespeople.

  • You can compare and contrast an almost limitless variety of cars until you narrow down a few top choices.

  • You won’t be given the ‘ole bait and switch (where the dealership lures you in to look at one car and quickly moves you on to a more expensive car on their lot, saying that one you wanted isn’t available). In fact, you can’t be upsold at all if the seller only has one car to sell.

  • You can examine the car in detail without a salesperson breathing down your neck.

  • If you buy from a private seller, you won’t have to pay hidden car dealership fees.

Cons of buying a car online

  • If you buy from a private seller, you’ll have to secure your own financing.

  • A dealership makes it easier to view and test drive various cars.

  • Buying a car from a private seller means you’re buying “as is,” which protects the seller from legal recourse should your car turn out to be a lemon. (That’s why it’s important to purchase a vehicle history report before you buy the car). On those same lines, you won’t have the option to purchase a warranty with the car as you would from a dealership.

  • You won’t be given an option to lease a car versus buy one if you’re going through a private seller.

  • If the car you want is located in another state, it’ll be harder to go see it, or you might have to commission a trustworthy mechanic in that location to take a look for you.

The one thing you MUST do to be sure you’re getting a good deal

If you weigh the pros and cons and decide that you want to buy your next car online, there’s one step you should absolutely never skip:

Look at the car in person before you buy.

We’ve all had that moment after an online purchase when the size and color weren’t quite what we thought, or the product’s condition was far worse in person than the picture would lead us to believe. Don’t think that can’t happen in online car purchases too.

In the case of the person who schooled me on buying cars online, he once had a seller tell him that the car came with all new parts. This, of course, sweetened the deal quite a bit. So my interviewee went to look at the car to make sure the seller was telling the truth.

He was … sort of. The seller failed to mention that those parts were still in boxes. In short, the buyer would have to do the work of installation, and you can forget about a test drive to make sure the car would run well. The car wasn’t even running yet.

No matter what you do, go see the car in person before you buy it. Going online is a great way to find cars, but not the place you should always try before you “buy.”

But are people really buying cars online?

Years ago, the idea of buying a car online might have sounded ludicrous — but nowadays, there are very few things that can’t be purchased online. What’s more, some recent data suggests that consumers are looking to the internet before buying their next car – and social media has a growing role in this process.

According to the J.D. Power 2016 New Autoshopper StudySM , 22 percent of online car shoppers use social media to help. That might not sound like much, but when you consider the number in 2015 was 16 percent, it’s clear that a trend is emerging. As for where these shoppers are looking, YouTube was the most popular of the social media websites, taking 13 percent of the total.

But consumers go beyond social media to narrow down the search. The study goes on to say that “more than nine out of 10 automotive internet shoppers visit at least one automaker’s site during the shopping process.” Of those shoppers, “84% visit a dealer site and 79% visit a third-party site.” In total, the study says that “On average, internet shoppers visit 10 automotive websites in their shopping process: four automotive manufacturer websites, three third-party websites and three dealership websites.”

Things get even more interesting as the study examines how consumers are using each type of website for different purposes:

“… automotive internet shoppers find that automotive brand sites are most useful for their model information, vehicle configurators and photo galleries, whereas dealer websites are found to be most useful for inventory searches, and vehicle pricing and third-party sites are most useful for vehicle ratings/reviews and vehicle comparisons.”

And if you’re curious which third-party websites consumers love, the study says that the top three (not in order) since 2012 have been Kelley Blue Book, Consumer Reports, and, with TrueCar growing in popularity.

Why consumers might prefer online to car dealerships

If you’re wondering why someone would take to the internet for a purchase as large as a car, a 2016 study done by car marketplace Vroom (then called Beepi), should shed some light. In the study, they found that 61 percent of the respondents felt “taken advantage of at least some of the time when shopping at a car dealership.” 

This discomfort led to the Millennial respondents saying they preferred a variety of what would typically be considered unpleasant activities over shopping for a car at a dealership. For example, 34 percent of respondents said they’d rather go to the DMV and 26 percent would rather work on their taxes. Gen X respondents also listed other things they’d rather do, including 24 percent who said they’d rather endure a root canal than try to negotiate at a car dealership.

All in all, the study concluded that 54 percent of the respondents “would love the ability to buy or sell a car without ever leaving home,” and 42 percent “would be comfortable purchasing a car online without a test drive if certain assurances (like a money-back guarantee) were in place.” In other words, if people have some kind of guarantee that they can return a car that isn’t working out, they might prefer to make the purchase online rather than in person at a car dealership.

This article originally appeared on and was syndicated by

Featured Image Credit: zorandimzr / iStock.