Bialys vs Bagels: Do You Really Know The Difference?

Featured

Written by:

Bialys are a breakfast bread winner. This personal portion-sized bread is a flat, round roll that’s perfectly chewy on the inside and crusty on the outside. Sometimes referred to as a “Jewish English muffin.”

Image Credit: bhofack2/Istockphoto.

What is a Bialy?

bialy (pronounced be-ALL-e) is a round Jewish bread that is a cross between a bagel and an English muffin, complete with nooks and crannies. Bialys are made of simple ingredients like yeast, flour, salt, and water. This handmade bread is commonly eaten at breakfast but can also be served as an accompaniment to lunch and dinner.

Named after Bialystok, Poland, bialys are short for bialystoker kuchen, which is Yiddish for “little bread from Bialystok.” This simple bread was brought by Polish Jewish immigrants to New York’s Lower East Side neighborhood in the late 1800s where it has stayed popular ever since.

Image Credit: Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys.

Bialys vs Bagels

Both bialys and bagels are breakfast and brunch staples that come in similar shapes and sizes, but these daily breads are distinct—and delicious! Unlike bagels, bialys do not have a hole but boast a slightly sunken center filled with (usually) diced onion instead. Bialys are hand pulled and baked whereas bagels are hand rolled then kettle boiled before being baked. While bialy bread may lack the sheen of bagels, they are just as dazzling. Plus, bialys are softer, chewier, and lighter than bagels, and the flavor is different because they lack the bagel’s sweet malt syrup.

Image Credit: Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys.

How to Eat a Bialy

Like bagels, bialys are toasted (or not!) and may be eaten plain or topped with savory toppings like a generous smear of butter or cream cheese. There’s no need to slice these babies—just take a bite. Seeking a heartier breakfast? You can slice bialys and make the perfect bialy sandwich, which variations like:

  • Classic nova and cream cheese
  • Bacon, egg, and cheese

Image Credit: Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys.

What is a Bialy Bagel?

Some people may refer to bialys as “bialy bagels,” but that’s actually a misnomer: As we’ve already discussed, bialys and bagels are actually two different things. Bialys and bagels are cousins, but they’re made completely differently. The dough used is the same, but the way they’re formed is different – bagels have a hole, and bialys don’t – and bagels are boiled before baking. One bite and it’ll be obvious that they’re different baked goods entirely.

Image Credit: Russ & Daughters.

Most Famous Bialys

The most famous bialys come from delis in New York City’s Lower East Side.

Classic Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys

Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys, the oldest bialy bakery in the United States, brick oven bakes your choice of their legendary bialys, including onion, garlic, sesame, and sundried tomato. Founded by Isadore Mirsky and Morris Kossar in 1936, the bagel and bialys shop also makes the best of both worlds with their Bialys + Bagels & Lox with a Schmear combo.

Image Credit: Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys.

Remarkable Russ & Daughters Bialys

The fourth generation appetizing shop Russ and Daughters ships its classic onion bialys straight from New York, Opened by Joel Russ in 1914, Russ passed the shop on to his daughters in the 1930s, and today it’s run by fourth-generation owners Josh Russ Tupper and Niki Russ Federman. This appetizing shop is one of the last to handmake Old World chewy bialys.

Image Credit: Russ & Daughters.

Sensational Sable’s Bialys

NYC’s Upper East Side smoked fish appetizing shop Sable’s is famed for smoked sable, but the appetizing shop bakes some of the best bialys too. Appetizing translates to “things that go with bagels” and Sable’s delivers with legendary brunch staples.

This article originally appeared on Goldbelly.com and was syndicated by MediaFeed.org.

Image Credit: Sable’s Bialys.

More from MediaFeed

These 13 Most Popular French Pastries Will Make Your Mouth Water

Image Credit: nobtis/Istockphoto.

AlertMe