As mortgage rates fluctuate, Americans question how much presidential policies influence housing costs. In reality, the connection isn’t as direct as campaign speeches suggest.
While voters hope new administrations will lower rates, economic and political factors play a bigger role.
Housing affordability remains a major concern. Examining historical trends and market forces helps clarify how policies shape the mortgage landscape—and what that means for buyers and homeowners. For those navigating today’s market, comparing the best mortgage lenders can help secure better rates and terms.
Image Credit: DepositPhotos.com.
The Federal Reserve’s Role in Mortgage Rates
The Federal Reserve influences mortgage rates through a specific chain of economic actions. Their primary tool is the federal funds rate, which affects borrowing costs between banks. This rate creates broad ripple effects in the economy, particularly on the 10-year Treasury yield—the benchmark mortgage lenders use to set their rates.
A clear example occurred in September 2024: The Fed lowered its rate by half a percent, but mortgage rates increased. This demonstrates how additional market forces can override even significant Fed policy changes.
Historical Election Impact Analysis
It’s helpful to examine historical trends to understand the true impact of presidential elections on mortgage rates. Data from 1972 to 2024 reveals no consistent correlation between elections and rate swings. Take a look at the chart below.
Image Credit: DepositPhotos.com.
Long-Term Trends (1972–2024)
- The following data from Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey examines 30-year fixed-rate mortgage averages during election periods. The starting rate represents the week of election day, while the ending rate reflects the rate approximately 30 days later.
Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1972
- Starting Rate: 7.43%
- Ending Rate: 7.44%
- Rate Effect: +0.10%
- Notable Context: Nixon re-election
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1976
- Starting Rate: 8.81%
- Ending Rate: 8.79%
- Rate Effect: -0.02%
- Notable Context: Carter victory
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1980
- Starting Rate: 14.21%
- Ending Rate: 14.79%
- Rate Effect: +0.58%
- Notable Context: Reagan victory, high inflation era
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1984
- Starting Rate: 13.64%
- Ending Rate: 14.18%
- Rate Effect: -0.46%
- Notable Context: Reagan re-election
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1988
- Starting Rate: 10.27%
- Ending Rate: 10.61%
- Rate Effect: +0.34%
- Notable Context: Bush victory
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1992
- Starting Rate: 8.31%
- Ending Rate: 8.21%
- Rate Effect: -0.10%
- Notable Context: Clinton victory
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 1996
- Starting Rate: 7.62%
- Ending Rate: 7.60%
- Rate Effect: -0.02%
- Notable Context: Clinton re-election
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 2000
- Starting Rate: 7.75%
- Ending Rate: 7.38%
- Rate Effect: -0.37%
- Notable Context: Bush victory
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 2004
- Starting Rate: 5.73%
- Ending Rate: 5.75%
- Rate Effect: +0.02%
- Notable Context: Bush re-election
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 2008
- Starting Rate: 6.09%
- Ending Rate: 5.29%
- Rate Effect: -0.80%
- Notable Context: Obama victory, Great Recession
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 2012
- Starting Rate: 3.66%
- Ending Rate: 3.62%
- Rate Effect: -0.04%
- Notable Context: Obama re-election
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 2016
- Starting Rate: 3.75%
- Ending Rate: 4.20%
- Rate Effect: +0.45%
- Notable Context: Trump victory
- Election Cycle: Nov-Dec 2020
- Starting Rate: 3.07%
- Ending Rate: 3.10%
- Rate Effect: +0.03%
- Notable Context: Biden victory, pandemic
- Election Cycle: 2024
- Starting Rate: 6.79%
- Ending Rate: 6.69%
- Rate Effect: -0.10%
- Notable Context: Trump victory, Harris conceded, Trump’s 2nd non-consecutive term
- Based on over 50 years of data, there’s no consistent correlation between presidential elections and mortgage rate movements. Rate changes during election periods have ranged from a significant decrease (-0.80% in 2008) to notable increases (+0.58% in 1980), with many elections showing minimal impact (less than ±0.10%).
Image Credit: Stocksy.
Policy-Driven Exceptions
- 2016: Rates increased after Trump’s first win due to anticipated inflationary policies
- 2020: The pandemic’s economic impact overshadowed election-related rate movements
The 2024 Election: A Case Study
Immediate Effect
The week of Election Day, November 5th, 30-year fixed mortgage rates averaged 6.79%. About 30 days later, on December 5th, they dipped slightly to 6.69%.
Market Reactions
Treasury yields surged post-Trump win, reflecting inflation fears. The yield on the 10-year Treasury climbed nearly 20 basis points to 4.48%, its highest level since early July.
This increase is attributed to traders gaining confidence that former President Donald Trump would secure a victory in Tuesday’s election and introduce inflationary measures, such as tariffs.
Analysts revised 2025 forecasts upward (6%-7% range). Lisa Sturtevant, chief economist at Bright MLS, predicts Trump’s fiscal strategies could cause mortgage rates to rise and become more volatile through the end of 2025. She no longer expects the average 30-year mortgage rate to fall below 6% next year.
Analysts from Raymond James and Associates also predict that mortgage rates will stay elevated for an extended period post-election.
Image Credit: Sitthiphong/istock.
Key Factors Overriding Election Cycles
Several key factors often override the direct impact of election cycles on mortgage rates. These include:
- Inflation expectations: Perhaps the most critical factor is inflation. Proposed policies, such as Trump’s tariffs and tax cuts, can be seen as inflationary triggers. Raymond James analysts suggest that these policies could lead to prolonged high rates.
- Global events: Geopolitical events, such as conflicts in the Middle East and Europe, can significantly influence bond markets and, consequently, mortgage rates. Uncertainty in these regions often drives investors towards safer assets like US Treasury bonds, affecting yields.
- Housing market dynamics: The dynamics within the housing market itself also play a crucial role. Low inventory, historically high cost of materials, and construction labor shortages continue to sustain high prices, impacting affordability and mortgage rates.
Image Credit: DepositPhotos.com.
2025 Outlook Under Trump’s Policies
Predictions for 2025 suggest that 30-year mortgage rates will likely oscillate between 6% and 7%. However, there is a risk of exceeding 7% if tariffs and other policies worsen inflation.
It’s important to note the contradiction between campaign promises and economist warnings. For instance, Trump’s pledge to bring mortgage rates down to 3% has been deemed unrealistic without triggering a recession.
Achieving such a low rate would likely require aggressive Fed intervention, which could adversely affect the economy.
Image Credit: DepositPhotos.com.
Strategic Advice for Homebuyers
Given the uncertainties and potential ups and downs in the mortgage market, here’s some straightforward advice for those looking to buy a home:
- Monitor treasury yields and fed meetings: Stay up-to-date on the more significant economic factors that affect mortgage rates. Understanding these trends can help you time your purchase.
- Consider adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs): ARMs might start with lower interest rates, but remember that those rates can change later on. This could be a good option if you expect your income to increase or if you plan to move in a few years.
- Explore first-time buyer programs: State and local programs often have grants, low-interest loans, or other benefits to help first-time homebuyers.
Image Credit: depositphotos.com.
Bottom Line
Presidential elections can influence mortgage rates by affecting policy and market confidence, but they’re just one piece of a larger economic puzzle.
Looking at the rest of 2025, factors like inflation control and overall economic health will likely have a stronger impact on mortgage rates than who occupies the White House.
For homebuyers, the smartest strategy goes beyond election cycles. Focus on what you can control: Building a strong credit score, finding the best mortgage lenders, and keeping your budget flexible.
This article originally appeared on bestmoney.com and was syndicated by MediaFeed.org.
Image Credit: Depositphotos.
